Book review: ‘Untold Story’ by Monica Ali

Maybe Princess Diana didn’t die.

Here’s a little something to rock your mind: you know Diana, beloved and ill-fated figure, mother of the future king of England and charitable woman extraordinaire? In Monica Ali’s imaginative novel Untold Story, her fate was not to die in a crash in a Paris tunnel. Though the world continues to mourn Diana, especially as the tenth anniversary of her death approaches, life has continued on.

And Lydia has tried to continue with it. In the American Midwest, a nondescript but pretty brunette with a lilting British accent lives a quiet life. Lydia passes the time working with animals and befriends a group of women in the quaint town of Kensington. In the years since she arrived in the U.S., no one has paid much attention to Lydia — except the men who drift in and out of her life, never gaining enough traction to crack her harsh exterior. Terrified of revealing too much of her background, Lydia has mastered the art of listening while offering little personal information. But someone from the past may not want the past to stay hidden . . .

Monica Ali’s Untold Story was a book I knew I had to read from the moment I got a glimpse of its cover. The black-and-white image clearly looks like Diana — and I’m trained to look for anything relating to the princess. My mother followed Diana closely; she was a very beloved figure in my household. When she died in 1997, Mom was absolutely devastated. She mourned Diana like she was family. She certainly felt like a friend.

When I worked at a local bookstore, I continually combed the shelves for anything new relating to Diana — and when I heard about Untold Story, it went straight on my wishlist. And while I found it to be a fascinating story and a creative reinterpretation of history, it didn’t bowl me over the way I’d hoped.

Ali, beloved author of works like Brick Lane, has quite the reputation in the literary community. She took a chance on Untold Story and I think it paid off — even if the book has been garnering much criticism. Here’s how I feel: few writers would gamble on something as weighty, meaty and controversial as writing an alternate history based on a beloved public figure’s death . . . and have her not die. I won’t reveal to you the hows or whats or whys, but I think it’s clear that Diana was in a bit of a tailspin at the time of her (real) death. Ali did a remarkable job of fleshing out the circumstances under which Diana became Lydia, and I believed it could happen.

The story’s real narrator — and the person to whom I felt closest — was Lawrence Standing, Diana’s fictional personal secretary. We’re given the background Lydia doesn’t share through Lawrence’s personal diary entries and know immediately that his health is poor. The narrative fluctuates between 2007 and the many years before, and Lawrence’s dated entries help us piece together the truth of what became of Diana. And Lydia.

What I found fascinating was that Diana’s name is never — not once — uttered by a single person anywhere in the novel. Through her transformation, Diana truly has become Lydia Snaresbrook, a woman with a truncated history who explains away her English ways by explaining only that she came to America with a husband she later left — a man who was not faithful to her (and that’s partially true). We all know Lydia is Diana. Of course we do. But no one else does, and that’s the real trick of the thing.

Here’s the thing: I read and read and read waiting for The Big Reveal. Based on dramatic tension, I knew there was no way Diana wasn’t going to be outed as Diana. What would her small town friends think? What would happen to the tiny American town of Kensington (cute), a place ill-equipped for the sudden fame it would experience? What in the world would become of Harry and William, Diana’s beloved boys, when they learned the truth of their mother’s fate.

But I was left with many questions and no answers. Ali does an admirable job sinking into Lydia’s psychosis and presents Diana as a paranoid, crazed, obsessive and desperate woman on the brink of disaster . . . and the rest of Untold Story seems to be an exploration of her grief. It’s impossible not to feel for Lydia/Diana, but she’s not a very likable person. I kept hoping the really good stuff would come in as the truth began to unravel, but I was left marooned on an island of Ali’s creation. I didn’t get any of the closure I sought.

I’m not going to get all saucy and scream, “Don’t read this book!” I mean, honestly — it’s not that bad. Disappointing and sad and a little long-winded, sure. It could absolutely have been better. But I’m not Monica Ali. Those decisions weren’t mine to make. If there had been more of an exploration of the media’s role in Diana’s death — both real and imagined in Untold Story — the story might have made for a weightier, more timely book. But armed only with this novel and its meandering plot, I have to say I’d hoped for more.


3 out of 5!

ISBN: 1451635486 ♥ GoodreadsLibraryThingAmazonAuthor Website
Personal copy borrowed from my local library

Advertisements

10 thoughts on “Book review: ‘Untold Story’ by Monica Ali

  1. I’m like your Mom and am obsessed with anything royal and so am really intrigued by this book. I think it’s an usual spin on things and so I want to read it. I’ve been suggesting it to my book club but so far they haven’t listened to me darn it 🙂

    • I hope they take you up on it someday! There would definitely be plenty to discuss in this one, and I think you’d have some interesting conversations regarding Diana’s imagined new life and the role of the media in her ongoing quest for peace.

  2. I was not all that fascinated with Diana, although I will never forget that she died on the day I announced to my family that I was pregnant with my first-born. It is tragic, and kind of fanciful to imagine that she isn’t really dead. There is some big potential there, but too bad it wasn’t realized.

    • That’s a powerful thing, Sandy: announcing your pregnancy on the day of her death. An forgettable moment. Though I wish the book had turned out differently, it’s not one I’ll forget — and Ali is a talented author.

  3. Awwww, I too was hoping for this book to have some exposure and exploration of the media’s role and maybe a big ending. I’m not a royal watcher but I do like a good story and Diana is someone a good story could be built around.

    • Maybe give it a try sometime, Leslie, and see you what you think — Diana/Lydia is a fascinating character, and the alternative history here was really interesting to think about!

  4. I am fascinated by the Royals and especially by Diana so this has been on my wishlist for awhile. I am disappointed to see the less than stellar reviews..

  5. I saw an ad for this one while I was home in the States and my first thought was, “weird.” Gotta admit that hasn’t changed – something about the very idea behind Ali’s novel repulses me. I tried reading Brick Lane and never made it past the first hundred pages, so her work isn’t a big draw for me…but something about this book in particular feels so OFF to me, regardless of my failed attempt read Ali in the past. Writing this novel at all is either a very gutsy move, as you write, or a calculated one; I just can’t get past thinking of the novel’s topic as a very calculated effort to garner attention and the sort of criticism that boosts sales. And Lydia Snaresbrook? What a name! I’m relieved that you wound up feeling unsatisfied by “Untold Story.” Frees me from wondering if I should give it a chance!

Comments are closed.