BBAW: Forgotten Treasures – ‘The Lost Art Of Keeping Secrets’

In keeping with our Book Blogger Appreciation Week festivities through Friday, today’s prompt asks us to mention a book we feel hasn’t gotten the exposure it ought — whether it be a classic, should-have-read-in-school novel or contemporary fiction that hasn’t found the audience it deserves.

So I’m going to tell you about a book, y’all.

It’s not that you haven’t heard me wax on ad nauseum about this one before. Eva Rice’s The Lost Art Of Keeping Secrets was one of my favorite reads of 2009, and easily wormed its way into my heart and mind, practically ruining me for other books.

As I said in my review last December,

No novel in recent memory has enchanted me more than Eva Rice’s The Lost Art Of Keeping Secrets. In fact, it’s going to be hard to even try and review it objectively — I just thought it was that magical, exciting, and engrossing, and if I could build a time machine and travel back to a time in which I hadn’t read this book, I’d be packing my suitcase and returning to last week, friends — let’s experience this novel all over again!

It’s the story of Penelope Wallace, a young woman growing up in post-war London who struggles mightly under the shadow of her beautiful mother — a woman who once knew the world was her oyster. After her father’s death in the war, Talitha retreats further into herself while her eccentricities compound. Never feeling good enough to impress her mother, Penelope loses herself in the music of Johnnie Ray, an American rock singer, as their once-immaculate, now-crumbling home disintegrates around them.

Penelope is waiting for a bus the day she meets Charlotte Ferris, a charismatic teen who immediately befriends Penelope and drags her to tea with her Aunt Clare. It’s there that’s introduced to an entirely new world: one of wealth, boredom and, as she meets Harry, Charlotte’s brother, infatuation. And maybe love.

Anything I crave in a novel was here — in spades. Dynamic, interesting and well-developed characters. Romance and a male lead with whom I became completely enamored, even if he was a little . . . unusual. Gorgeous, lush and inviting scenery — and Milton Magna, their old castle, which had a life of its own (and happened to be in England, my favorite place). A fast-paced, emotional plot that kept me engaged from page one. Realistic, funny dialogue. A love affair with music and devotion to a singer with which I could immediately and directly relate.

Yes, friends, The Lost Art Of Keeping Secrets was phenomenal. Through everything, I think of it as “my book” — and just yesterday, I got a new comment on my review from someone who felt the same way. I’m not one to brag, but I’ve converted a few folks on this one — including Emily from Emily And Her Little Pink Notes, and my baby sister.

I don’t know if it’s a book for everyone, but it was definitely a book for me. In fact, if ever I felt like a novel had been written with my specific interests in mind, it’s Eva Rice’s. If it sounds like there’s something here for you, please don’t hesitate to pick it up. Though I was initially drawn in by the cover, it’s what happened between the pages that kept me captivated and gushing about it . . . all these months later.

Check out more reviews on LibraryThing and Goodreads, then add it to your wishlist. If you’re completely captivated and have to have it now, add it to your cart at the Book Depository (free shipping!), Amazon (where it’s currently bargain priced at $4.48!), Powell’s or indiebound.

24 thoughts on “BBAW: Forgotten Treasures – ‘The Lost Art Of Keeping Secrets’

  1. Meg, I’ve wanted to read this ever since you suggested it to me a couple of months ago but in an UTTER TRAVESTY our library doesn’t have it! So I’d better cough up: you make it sound so amazing.


  2. I have added this one to my list! If there’s anything more delicious than a book with “a fast-paced emotional plot,” it’s one with lush settings.

    Sounds wonderful!

    Thanks for visiting my blog, and I’ve added your URL to my notebook of blogs to visit.


  3. Thanks for dropping by my blog! I never thought about it that way but I guess Half Magic can be considered magic realism. It’s a completely different take on it from Sarah Addison Allen’s use of magic in Garden Spells, but I really enjoyed both books. Any other books in the ‘magic realism’ genre you could recommend?

    Also I’ve heard great things about The Lost Art of Keeping Secrets, so I should probably check it out!


  4. I won’t know for sure until I read it but I think you’ve converted me already! lol This sounds like a wonderful book with most of the things I hope to find in a great book. I am especially interested in Penelope and I love good dialogue especially when it’s funny.

    I am going to try to pick this book up very soon!
    Thanks Meg!
    ~ Amy


  5. I must have somehow missed your original review of this book. But it sounds intriguing and after seeing that someone on Goodreads recommended it for people who liked “Atonement” and “I Capture the Castle”, I have added it to my “to-read” list. Now to finish the three books I have going right now. 😀 Thanks for the recommendation!


  6. Hey, I don’t need to add this to my out of control wish list, because…. I have it already! Now I just need to rescue it from its home on the shelf and actually read it! Thanks for the nudge. 😉


  7. I agree completely! I’ve never met anyone who’s even heard of this book and it’s my favorite thing that I’ve read in the past five years. It has such a dreamy movielike quality about it. I bought a copy immediately after reading. I’m glad you’ve introduced more readers to this book.


  8. Wow, that sounds like an incredibly powerful book – and an amazing author, to be able to make you feel what the character is feeling! Might check this out, but I have to admit I’m slightly nervous now. :/


Comments are closed.